Side Banner

Member Reviews

No good movie is too long and no bad movie is short enough. Your intellect may be confused, but your emotions will never lie to you.

You can also browse reviews using our alphabetical index of films reviewed

Films reviewed on this Page

Dupahiya (1)
Nadaaniyan (6)
The Waking of a Nation (1)
Mithya (1)
Sthal (1)

Page 3 of 82

Dupahiya
Shubhra Gupta
The Indian Express
Gajraj Rao, Renuka Shahane’s anti-Mirzapur show delivers clean, family entertainment

Gajraj Rao, Renuka Shahane's ruralcom delivers clean, socially-relevant family entertainment. The show has a determinedly cheerful air -- leaving the viewer smiling is clearly the mandate.

A stolen motorcycle– ‘dupahiya’– in the fictional village of Dhadakpur becomes the fulcrum around which this new comedy and its characters revolve, delivering a melange of Bihari-via-Mumbai accents, loads of quirk and broad life lessons. This is the mix that gave ‘Panchayat’ its mojo, with Phulera’s Sachivji and Pradhanji and their cohorts becoming a byword in the madly-popular OTT-specific ruralcom genre. Here, Uttar Pradesh is replaced by Bihar, but the mood remains similarly overall sunny, as the occasional clouds created by the busy plot (written by Avinash Dwivedi and Chirag Garg) are dispelled by the show’s determinedly cheerful air: leave the viewer smiling is clearly the mandate.

Continue reading …

All 3 reviews of Dupahiya here

Nadaaniyan
Shubhra Gupta
The Indian Express
Ibrahim Ali Khan, Khushi Kapoor film rehashes every Karan Johar romcom, without his sparkle

Ibrahim Ali Khan and Khushi Kapoor-starrer, directed by first-timer Shauna Gautam, has been created by-and-for hashtags, with zero insights into the demographic it represents.

Take the Dharma template because, duh, this is a Dharma film, borrow deets from a bunch of romcoms, shake ’em up, and you get Nadaaniyan. There’s the swish high-school from ‘Kuch Kuch Hota Hai’, which lead character Pia Jaisingh (Khushi Kapoor) helpfully describes as having ‘no-uniform, resort-type vibes’, just in case we miss it. Ms Braganza (Archana Puran Singh, reprising her role, older but not wiser) is back. No student ever seems to go to class: that’s not changed, either. And those who’ve been missing that shooting star, so cute, ya, fear not: it gets a look-see, too.

Continue reading …

All 17 reviews of Nadaaniyan here

The Waking of a Nation
Bharathi Pradhan
Lehren.com
The Conspiracy Behind The Jallianwala Bagh Massacre

The Waking of a Nation' tells the story of Kantilal, a fictional member of the Hunter Commission, who tries to uncover the truth behind the Jallianwala Bagh massacre, risking his life after General Dyer orders the shooting.

It was a blood splattered Baisakhi on April 13, 1919. When a jashan (celebration) turned into a janazaa (funeral) for the hundreds gunned down at Jallianwala Bagh, Amritsar. General Dyer went down in history as the butcher. He was the cruel perpetrator, also the puppet. But mastermind, ringmaster and puppeteer Lieutenant-General Michael O’Dwyer was never formally indicted. (Udham Singh did shoot him dead more than 20 years later.) Is it time for an unwritten chapter to be brought to the fore? Director Ram Madhvani who had shown glimpses of how well he can segue imagination into history when he made the short film That Bloody Line (on how Sir Cyril Radcliffe cut off bits of India on the west and on the east), goes down the same path, same era.This time to recreate the Amritsar of 1919.

Continue reading …

All 3 reviews of The Waking of a Nation here

Nadaaniyan
Bharathi Pradhan
Lehren.com
Juvenile, Actually

This Love-Tale is full of Nadaaniyan as Ibrahim & Khushi are Ishq Mein together! But is all the young romance worth a watch?

The Principal’s dying to be cool. The acronym-loving kind of cool that says YOLO, You Only Live Once. That’s a hat tip from debut-making director Shauna Gautam to mentor Karan Johar in whose debut film Kuch Kuch Hota Hai, Archana Puran Singh had played the same ditzy role. The rest of the film too, continues to be Johar territory, revisited, recycled. I’m going to cut some slack for the freshers behind and on screen. This is a new start for the director and for new hero Ibrahim Ali Khan (playing ‘Noyyda’ boy Arjun) while it’s a third attempt for Khushi Kapoor (Pia Jaisingh).

Continue reading …

All 17 reviews of Nadaaniyan here

Nadaaniyan
Bhawana Somaaya
92.7 Big FM
Nadaniyan reflects our urban youth who are confused but eventually accountable for their actions
All 17 reviews of Nadaaniyan here

Nadaaniyan
Uday Bhatia
Mint Lounge
The kids never stood a chance

This uninspired, unsure film hangs Khushi Kapoor and Ibrahim Ali Khan out to dry

Star kid releases have become a toxic cycle in Hindi film. No one seems to derive any pleasure from them, yet there’s one every month. As soon as a trailer drops, thousands of angry posts appear, with nothing to go on but two minutes of promotion and a vague idea that sons and daughters of famous actors are the enemy. Even established stars who came through film families can’t catch a break; last year, the release of Jigra, starring Alia Bhatt, was marked by unprecedented negativity. But with the younger crop, there are problems beyond an apathetic and frustrated Hindi viewing public.

Continue reading …

All 17 reviews of Nadaaniyan here

Mithya
Manoj Kumar
Independent Film Critic
A poignant drama that closes with a nail-biting finish

Mithya explores layers of grief in a young boy’s life, but it also reflects a growing desire within the Kannada film industry to tell stories that offer real value to audiences.

Mithya is an intimate story of a young boy struggling to make sense of his life, which has been shattered into countless pieces after his parents pass away. It marks director Sumanth Bhat’s feature film debut. Previously, he helmed the Kannada web series Ekam, also co-produced by Rakshit Shetty. Mithya sheds light on the internal turmoil of an 11-year-old boy, Mithun. Taken in by his aunt’s family after his mother dies by suicide — leaving him and his younger sister orphaned — he is uprooted from Mumbai, where he was born and raised, and placed in the slow, quiet countryside of Udupi. He prefers to be called Mithya, but adjusting to his new reality is far from easy.

Continue reading …

All 4 reviews of Mithya here

Sthal
Keyur Seta (for The Common Man Speaks) 
Bollywood Hungama
Subtle yet powerful critique of forced arranged marriages of girls

India is obsessed with marriages. Weddings take place all over the country in different regions and among different communities and they are celebrated like anything. However, even in today’s times in rural India, the idea of a girl’s forced arranged marriage still exists. Filmmaker Jayant Digambar Somalkar’s Sthal (A Match) boldly highlights this social evil. The movie takes place in a village in Maharashtra named Dongargaon and it revolves around Savita Daulatrao Wandhare (Nandini Chikte). She is in her Final year of Bachelor of Arts course and her specialization subject is Sociology. Her father (Taranath Khiratkar) and mother (Sangita Sonekar) wish to get her married off soon but she wants to study further.

Continue reading …

All 3 reviews of Sthal here

Nadaaniyan
Nonika Singh
The Tribune, Hollywood Reporter India
Love me not, the film cries out

For the longest time, Dharma Productions has been known for reminding us how rich lives matter. Time and again, it has taken viewers not only on a voyeuristic ride into the extravagant lifestyles of the uber rich, but also offered a deep dive into their ‘struggles’, often evoking a fair degree of empathy, even relatability. ‘Nadaaniyan’ is one more such film where the poor rich girl syndrome manifests itself. Pia (Khushi Kapoor) is the daughter of ultra-rich parents (Suniel Shetty and Mahima Chaudhry), studying in an ‘ultra-elite school’ where students seem to be doing anything but study. She, ‘the poster princess of privilege and entitlement’, has her fair share of dilemmas, including her parents’ failing marriage.

Continue reading …

All 17 reviews of Nadaaniyan here

Nadaaniyan
Renuka Vyavahare
The Times of India
A rambling love story that’s too filtered to be true

Despite the potential, the storytelling and emotions in Nadaaniyan are as shallow and filtered as beautified Instagram posts.

To win over her best friends and wriggle out of a sticky situation, poor little rich girl Pia Jaisingh (Khushi Kapoor) convinces her new classmate, a career-driven Arjun Mehta (Ibrahim Ali Khan) to be her rental boyfriend. The Instagram love story looks perfect on reels until things get real between the two. You can predict this story as soon as it begins. It follows the tropes of any teen romance. Pia offers Rs 25K a week to Arjun, an aspiring lawyer to get him to pretend as her boyfriend. She’s a wealthy Delhi girl; he’s from Greater Noida. He thinks love is a distraction, she thinks her world revolves around love. Her family’s patriarchal, his parents are liberal. Despite the differences, the two make a deal. She soft launches him on her socials before the big reveal. What happens when the two catch feelings?

Continue reading …

All 17 reviews of Nadaaniyan here