Side Banner
Recent Reviews by Vishal Menon
The Hollywood Reporter India

Vishal Menon is the Assoiciate Editor at The Hollywood Reporter, India. He was previously with Film Companion and The Hindu. He writes about Malayalam and Tamil Cinema.

Films reviewed on this Page

Sookshmadarshini
Her
Sorgavaasal
Kanguva
Amaran
Bougainvillea
Vettaiyan

Sookshmadarshini
Nazriya Nazim, Basil Joseph Light Up This Hitchcockian Comedy

Filmmaker MC Jithin presents a compelling mix of genres featuring strong leads and stronger direction.

The first 20 minutes of Sookshmadarshini may be used as a textbook to learn the art of writing a setup. Writers Athul Ramachandran and Libin TB are preparing their viewer for a film that falls into an unusual genre but instead of rushing towards the plot, they take their time to focus on establishing their protagonist: Priyadarshini (Nazriya), a 20-something mother who admits to feeling bored of domesticity. She lives in a regular middle-class neighbourhood, filled with regulars who know everything about each other.

Continue reading …

All 2 reviews of Sookshmadarshini here

Her

Also starring the likes of Parvathy Thiruvothu, Lijomol Jose, Remya Nambeesan and Aishwarya Rajesh, this mix of complex stories is told with the lightness of listening to a friend speaking straight from the heart.

It’s not fair to call Lijin Jose’s Her, written by Archana Vasudev, an anthology. On the surface, these are the stories of five women taking place across five households in and around Thiruvananthapuram. The timelines are jumbled and these stories are set across different genres with at least one comedy, one satire and parts you can broadly call drama, each with its own mood and theme. Yet you feel conflicted by the thought of calling it an anthology because it never stops feeling like a unified whole, with the narrative smoothness of a well-written feature film (it’s edited by Kiran Das).

Continue reading …

All 2 reviews of Her here

Sorgavaasal
RJ Balaji Stars In A Largely Compelling Update Of ‘Virumaandi’

Director and co-writer Sidharth Viswanathan relies on the strong performances of the cast and the writing to keep this prison drama accessible and mainstream

There couldn’t have been a more fitting title for the film that Sorgavaasal has turned out to be. When translated, it could be read as “At Heaven’s Gate”. This isn’t merely ironic, given how almost the entire film is set within the walls of a high-security prison. But the idea of being at arms length from heaven, as close as you are far, gives Sorgavaasal the illusion of it taking place in some sort of a purgatory. For some inmates, this idea of heaven is the day they’re released back into the outside world. For others, the exit sign points only towards death. But then there’s the third kind, like the man they all lovingly call ‘Cooker’ (Balaji Sakthivel), whose belief falls somewhere in between. When Parthi (RJ Balaji, as never seen before) cooks a delicious meal for the inmates, he asks Cooker why this isn’t the norm. Cooker replies, “If you start enjoying the food you’re being served here, you will feel no need to leave.”

Continue reading …

All 4 reviews of Sorgavaasal here

Kanguva
All 10 reviews of Kanguva here

Amaran
An Earnest Sivakarthikeyan, Stellar Battle Sequences, Middling Drama

The film is sustained by the power of its source material and its inspirational hero, rather than its filmmaking.

In one of the many interesting segues in Rajkumar Periasamy’s Amaran, an officer talks to Major Mukund Varadarajan (an earnest Sivakarthikeyan) about the Kashimir women these officers refer to as “half widows”, stuck in perennial conflict as they wait for their husbands to return, unsure if they’re still alive. This is explained in a rush, as though someone is reading aloud a Wikipedia entry, but one can still make a connection between these women and the film’s narrator,

Continue reading …

All 7 reviews of Amaran here

Bougainvillea
A Gripping Mind Game With Stellar Acts

The film potently uses the unreliable narrator trope to fully immerse the audience into a story about “gaslighting” and domestic abuse.

Amal Neerad and his co-writer Lajo Jose (whose story this film is based on) know how far to push the unreliable narrator trope. Not only is their protagonist Reethu (Jyothirmayi in her return) suffering from both retrograde and anterograde amnesia, but we’re seeing the film through her perspective for the most part. What makes this film even more complex is how quickly we get the feeling that we cannot rely on the people Reethu relies on to make sense of her chilling universe.

Continue reading …

All 6 reviews of Bougainvillea here

Bougainvillea
All 6 reviews of Bougainvillea here

Vettaiyan
Unsubtle, Clunky But Engaging

A cop drama using cinematic tropes to make you rethink who you should be whistling for.

Journalist-turned-director T. J. Gnanavel doesn’t seem to care much for any sort of filmmaking subtleties. It’s as though he enjoys dialling up the volume knob to underline his already-dramatic writing, and doesn’t let you rest until you feel the full weight of a scene’s emotions. This was obvious in the way he didn’t stop by just showing you a police officer dragging a beaten-up Manikandan K. into the back of a police jeep in Jai Bhim (2021).

Continue reading …

All 7 reviews of Vettaiyan here