
Recent Reviews by Shubhra Gupta
The Indian Express

Shubhra Gupta, a senior columnist and acclaimed film critic at The Indian Express, boasts over 30 years of experience with her widely-read weekly review column. A prominent figure in India’s film criticism scene, she frequently attends global film festivals and has served on national and international juries. She curates and conducts the hugely popular platform, The Indian Express Film Club, in Delhi and Mumbai.
Films reviewed on this Page
Baby John
Girls Will Be Girls
Yeh Kaali Kaali Ankhein S02
Agni
Bandish Bandits S02
Despatch
Sikandar Ka Muqaddar
All We Imagine as Light
Waack Girls
I Want to Talk
Baby John

Bloated and incoherent, Varun Dhawan film among the worst of 2024
The trouble with this Atlee production, a remake of Vijay’s 2016 hit Theri, with which Varun Dhawan gets his big fat South masala film, is that very little sticks.
At a late stage in the film, Rajpal Yadav’s character, who plays a side-kick to the hero, gets the best line of Baby John: comedy is serious business. It was about the only time I heard a ripple of laughter in the preview theatre. It is the kind of punchline that masala movies use to bring the house down. And it says a great deal about Baby John, which weighs in at a punishing 164 minutes, that a comic’s dialogue gets more taalis than the hero’s ‘taqia kalaam’ line: ‘par main toh pehli baar aaya hoon’.
All 13 reviews of Baby John here
Girls Will Be Girls

Kani Kusruti takes your breath away in one of the best films of 2024
The three lead players carry the film -- Kesav Binoy Kiron adds the right dollop of barely-there smarm to his charm. When Panigrahi and Kusruti, are facing off, you can’t take your eyes off either.
In an unspecified North Indian hilltown boarding school, a girl comes of age. That overused phrase ‘coming-of-age’ is a misnomer when it comes to mainstream Hindi cinema: the years between thirteen and eighteen are those where contradictory impulses leap between synapses, with mind and body taking off in opposite directions, and explorations of both taking you into spaces where you’ve never been before.
All 10 reviews of Girls Will Be Girls here
Yeh Kaali Kaali Ankhein S02

Tahir Raj Bhasin, Saurabh Shukla show never takes its eyes off the ball
Tahir Raj Bhasin, Saurabh Shukla and Shweta Tripathi-starrer , with all its pulpy thriller sinews in place, leaves us on a cliffhanger, nicely primed for the next season.
The first season of ‘Yeh Kaali Kaali Aankhein’ became an addictive watch in the way it bent one of the oldest genres in the book: being an obsessive lover is not just a male prerogative; women can do it just as well, if not better. It made up for all its nods to hoary Hindi movie heavies who lived in palaces overrun by armed goons, governed by old-style off-with-their-heads villainy.
All 3 reviews of Yeh Kaali Kaali Ankhein S02 here
Agni

Pratik Gandhi is excellent in Rahul Dholakia’s damp film
Rahul Dholakia's film honours the commitment that heroic firefighters have to their jobs, even as they rail against ‘the system’ which doesn’t give them the support they need.
Hindi movies have played with fire several times before. Those with long memories will remember such films as the 1980 adventure ‘The Burning Train’, which may have picked up inspiration from an earlier Hollywood blockbuster ‘The Towering Inferno’, but those who fight the flames at the risk of their own lives, have never been in the limelight.
All 5 reviews of Agni here
Bandish Bandits S02

No straggly spots, only the sound of music
Each actor contributes to the show, and the leads are excellent. Some really good music comes up through these plot devices which makes us stay.
The face-off between tradition and modernity, past and present, the strict rules of gharana-and-parampara vs doing-your-own-thing, which were the key notes of the first season of ‘Bandish Bandits’, are back again in the second. As are many of the actors, reprising their roles, along with new faces, as the story takes off from where it left off, back in 2020.
All 4 reviews of Bandish Bandits S02 here
Despatch

Manoj Bajpayee doesn’t get the film he deserves
The film never cements its pieces together enough to create a coherent picture. Its telling feels disjointed, and its characters come and go, leaving us in limbo.
Crime reporter Joy Bag (Manoj Bajpayee) is not the kind of journalist we see too often in Hindi movies. His favourite accompaniment is his rucksack, as he goes about criss-crossing the city on his bike, in search of the latest story. He’s been doing this for a while, because he talks to his seniors like an equal, but at heart he will always remain a scrappy newshound who likes nothing better than chatting up shadowy contacts over cups of cheap cutting chai, which he prefers to the pizza his wife serves at unwelcome parties at home.
All 9 reviews of Despatch here
Sikandar Ka Muqaddar

Neeraj Pandey’s Netflix film is a rare beast in Bollywood, a pulpy character study with twists you don’t see coming
Neeraj Pandey's Netflix heist movie soars on the strength of plot and performance, with stars servicing the story, just the way it should be.
A large jewellery exhibition in Mumbai becomes the site of a heist. A hysterical phone call raises alarm, gunfire is heard, the cops on duty herd the panicked gathering into a secluded area, and during the melee, a fistful of precious gems go missing.
All 9 reviews of Sikandar Ka Muqaddar here
All We Imagine as Light

Payal Kapadia’s lyrical ode to working-class Mumbai and female friendship
The wonderful Kani Kusruti turns yearning into a full-time job, and just for her, this film which releases in India today, is worth every minute of your time.
A woman leans on a pole in her compartment, for support, for balance, swaying with the rhythm of the train. She looks exhausted, after a long day at work. We take in, like she does, the way the city looks at night, bars of refracted light and darkness dancing across her face. This image, which comes early in Payal Kapadia’s lyrical ode to working-class Mumbai and female friendship, becomes a marker of the themes the film explores, and it stays with you.
All 7 reviews of All We Imagine as Light here
Waack Girls

Prime Video show is good-natured, well-intentioned
Some of the most engaging parts of the show, co-written by Taraporevala, Iyanah Batlivala, and Ronny Sen are those, ironically, when there’s no dancing.
An underdog dance group making something of itself: right from the opening frame of Waack Girls, you know that this will be the trajectory of this rag-tag bunch, based in Kolkata. But this Sooni Taraporevala-created-and-directed nine part series attempts to build in differentials. First off, Kolkata is still not a city you’d think of when it comes to street style dancing and underground meetings where dance-offs occur. A lovely Cal feeling is captured in a crumbling old mansion, in a tony club, in the corner puchka-wala, and in the accents people use. You do see some familiar structures on the skyline, like the Howrah Bridge, but they are just there, no emphasis laid. That is refreshing.
I Want to Talk

Abhishek Bachchan’s performance is better than anything else he’s done so far, but Shoojit Sircar’s drama is too understated
Abhishek Bachchan lets go of vanity, revealing a thickened gut, and scars-on-the-belly, and an ability to bare. But Shoojit Sircar's film leaves you wanting more.
Going into ‘I Want To Talk’, I had no idea that that the character Abhishek Bachchan plays is based on an actual person called Arjun Sen. That knowledge would have added a certain layer to the story of a man who bests certain death- a diagnosis of laryngeal cancer and the consequent grim prognosis of a limited future—and is still around on planet earth. A valid question arises, after you’re done: anyone surviving 19-20 tough surgeries, and finding the energy to bring up a daughter, and run a marathon, is worthy of respect, but is that enough to engage us for two hours? Director Shoojit Sircar has an affinity for characters dealing with life-and-death situations, set in the innards of hospitals (October), as well as exploring filial connections (Piku). Both themes are here, but the depth and emotion which elevate his plots surface only occasionally.