Recent Reviews by Saibal Chatterjee
NDTV
Saibal Chatterjee is an independent film critic based in Delhi. His weekly reviews appear on www.ndtv.com. He also writes on cinema for The Tribune and The Gulf Today newspapers.
Films reviewed on this Page
Black Warrant
Parama: A Journey With Aparna Sen
Girls Will Be Girls
Despatch
Rhythm of Dammam
Sikandar Ka Muqaddar
I Want to Talk
Greedy People
Nayanthara: Beyond the Fairy Tale
Kanguva
Black Warrant
Firmly Focussed Series Warrants Bingeing On
An absorbing story of a baptism by fire and an insightful snapshot of an era in the life of a nation
Jailers, convicts and undertrials populate Black Warrant, a seven-episode Netflix series created by Vikramaditya Motwane and Satyanshu Singh and produced under the banner of Applause Entertainment. Barring occasional detours beyond its prison setting, the show remains firmly focussed on an upright, unassuming jailer navigating a corrupt, insensitive system. It provides a sprawling overview of Delhi’s understaffed and overcrowded Tihar Jail of the 1980s from the perspective of a real-life prison superintendent. The insider’s take sets the series apart from average yarns about cops and crooks, crime and punishment. Black Warrant is no yarn. Rooted in reality, it portrays the intense struggles of a hero who is anything but a boilerplate man of action. He isn’t a cocky, hyper-masculine, strapping crusader out to flatten everything in his path.
All 10 reviews of Black Warrant here
Parama: A Journey With Aparna Sen
Overdue Documentary Should Be Essential Viewing
Parama: A Journey with Aparna Sen had its world premiere at the International Film Festival Rotterdam 2024
Aparna Sen, movie star, ace filmmaker, successful magazine editor and active civil society leader, has had an incredibly eventful and diverse career. A documentary chronicling her life and times was long overdue. But that certainly isn’t the only reason why Suman Ghosh’s Parama: A Journey with Aparna Sen, should be essential viewing. Straddling a wide gamut - from the personal and professional to the political and public - and employing a wide range of interviews and reminiscences of notable contemporaries, Parama: A Journey with Aparna Sen throws light on an accomplished filmmaker, her significant body of work and the complexities of the times that she lives and works in. Suman Ghosh, who cast Aparna Sen alongside Soumitra Chatterjee in Basu Poribar (2018), has produced a deft 81-minute cinematic document that encapsulates the varied facets of one of India’s foremost filmmakers. The female gaze and the primacy of films that put women at their centre are inevitably mentioned, but Ghosh, taking a cue from the subject’s stand on the matter, does not unduly foreground Sen’s gender.
All 2 reviews of Parama: A Journey With Aparna Sen here
Girls Will Be Girls
It's Spellbindingly Granular And Resonantly Universal
It's buoyed by impeccable writing and a couple of consummate performances by debutante Preeti Panigrahi and the seasoned Kani Kusruti.
A brilliant and sensitive schoolgirl in love with a classmate is watched, monitored and scrutinised incessantly as she seeks to break free from familial and societal shackles in Girls Will Be Girls, writer-director Shuchi Talati’s self-assured, award-winning narrative feature debut now streaming on Amazon Prime Video. The exquisitely crafted and insightful coming-of-age drama, an Indo-French co-production that bagged two awards at the Sundance Film Festival this year, is buoyed by impeccable writing and a couple of consummate performances by debutante Preeti Panigrahi and the seasoned Kani Kusruti.
All 10 reviews of Girls Will Be Girls here
Despatch
If You've Had Enough Of The Mayhem Perpetrated By Pushpa 2, This Is The Film For You
It is a solid and pointed probe into a profession in crisis and a life in the doldrums.
Two early scenes in Despatch provide a foretaste of the complexities that are about to assail the life of crime reporter Joy Bag (Manoj Bajpayee). In the first, he returns home from a long day at work to find wife Shweta (Shahana Goswami) merrily partying with friends. One of the guests, drunk to the gills, tries to forcibly feed him a pizza. Joy snaps and storms out of the house.
All 9 reviews of Despatch here
Rhythm of Dammam
An Exceptionally Evocative, Visually Arresting Film
Hitting all the right notes, the film laments the undermining of a civilisational tapestry that thrives on diversity
The Siddis, a community unrepresented in Indian cinema, is under the spotlight in Rhythm of Dammam, an exceptionally evocative, visually arresting film written and directed by Kerala-born, New York-based Jayan Cherian. The film premiered this week at the 55th International Film Festival of India in Goa. It is now headed to the International Competition line-up of the upcoming 29th International Film Festival of Kerala.
Sikandar Ka Muqaddar
The Film Has Neither Spark Nor Sparkle
It packs into its runtime of nearly two and a half hours are all perfectly in order until the makers seek to turn the clock back so much that the whole contraption is on the brink of collapsing in an ungainly heap.
Think up a character. Name him Sikandar. He may or may not master of his destiny. Pit the clean-cut guy against a dogged lawman determined to control the man’s muqaddar. Lo and behold, you have a handy title that harks back to a 1978 Amitabh Bachchan megahit with which this Netflix film has nothing to do.
All 9 reviews of Sikandar Ka Muqaddar here
I Want to Talk
Abhishek Bachchan Delivers A Flawless And Profoundly Moving Performance
It touches an instant chord and is achingly life-affirming even as it is acutely aware of our fragility and transience.
The intimation of death signals the beginning of a new life in the here and now for Arjun Sen, the voluble and showy adman-protagonist of Shoojit Sircar’s I Want to Talk. It inevitably causes confusion and agony but strengthens his resolve to fight while altering his perspective on existence and mortality. Written by Ritesh Shah and based on a real-life Indian-American professional, Arjun produces adverts to encourage people to buy products they might or might not need. His joys rest on the sterling success he has in pulling off his acts of persuasion.
All 10 reviews of I Want to Talk here
Greedy People
The Film Has Its Share Of Passably Bright Moments
The film is marred a touch by a marked lack of chemistry between the two male actors but that lacuna actually seems intended at times.
A brisk opening that holds some promise, a meandering middle that scuttles much of the early potential, and an overly rushed climax make Greedy People a mixed bag – an action comedy that never kicks into top gear despite all the scampering that it does in search of a sweep spot. Greedy People, premiering in India exclusively on Lionsgate Play and available in English and Hindi, is frequently enlivened by dashes of deadpan humour. With Joseph Gordon-Levitt imparting immense charm and chutzpah to his flamboyant cop and punchlines flying thick and fast between him and his partner in ‘crime’, the film has its share of passably bright moments.
All 2 reviews of Greedy People here
Nayanthara: Beyond the Fairy Tale
The Documentary Serves Its Purpose To Perfection
The tale begins of course with her birth into the family of an Indian Air Force officer and his homemaker-wife (whose role in Nayanthara's life is repeatedly emphasised).
In an industry overwhelmingly dominated by men, Nayanthara is a rarity. A “lady superstar” who earned her spurs the hard way and went on to upend many an established showbiz norm, she has over the years fronted numerous big South Indian films that have ridden on her crowd-pulling prowess. This self-produced Netflix documentary seeks to capture the rise and rise of Nayanthara in the face of several reverses. It isn’t an objective account but, notwithstanding the limitations of its format, Nayanthara: Beyond The Fairy Tale is entertaining and insightful.
All 3 reviews of Nayanthara: Beyond the Fairy Tale here
Kanguva
Its Intent On Being The Tamil Baahubali And KGF Remains Untapped
Kanguva is a visual treat enhanced by Suriya's tremendous screen presencekanguva-7
Its ambition is sky-high. Kanguva seeks to derive power from the elements (wind, water and fire), the ambitious merger of two timelines separated by a millennium, and the immense magnetism of lead actor Suriya. Nothing wrong with that of course, but the building blocks would have come together far more effectively had the writing and treatment been more organised and coherent.