data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/56dcf/56dcfb8a0c142012b7287b59fb5083b3ab7c6a4b" alt="Side Banner"
Recent Reviews by Rohan Naahar
The Indian Express
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fe48e/fe48e3ecdb78d7b0165c8be362fdff4fdb1cf6eb" alt=""
Rohan Naahar is based out of New Delhi, India, and has been reviewing films and television shows for over a decade. He has written for the Hindustan Times and currently writes for the Indian Express.
Films reviewed on this Page
Black Doves
Emilia Pérez
Senna
Woman of the Hour
Joy
The Piano Lesson
Girls Will Be Girls
Singham Again
Don't Move
Santosh
Black Doves
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/be2f0/be2f0df4b1c09a1f2353e7b4bce0f6a2d6f8a6c6" alt=""
Classy and kinetic, Keira Knightley’s Netflix spy series is an unmissable romp
Starring Keira Knightley and Ben Whishaw, Netflix's new spy series is far superior to the scores of other espionage offerings out there.
In the almost criminally enjoyable new Netflix series Black Doves, Keira Knightley and Ben Whishaw play a chic housewife and her gay best friend who just happen to be covert operatives. They straddle dual identities, as does the show, which can often juggle tones with the deftness of a circus performer. Black Doves is at once a complex espionage thriller, a cheekily humorous dark comedy, and when it needs to be, a dreary domestic drama. It soars on the strength of its two central performances, and writing that is both self-aware and endearingly sincere.
Emilia Pérez
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4864e/4864e849b3950cf74f97dd670999f837c8439860" alt=""
Jacques Audiard’s audacious new film is like a cross between Chachi 420 and Dog Day Afternoon
acques Audiard's new film, dances to its own tune; it's a musical, a crime thriller, and a redemption tale. It's among the most ambitious films of the year.
Did the French auteur Jacques Audiard watch Chachi 420 and feel inspired to make his latest film, Emilia Pérez? Stranger things have happened this year. Nick Jonas has celebrated Holi in Greater Noida, and Ed Sheeran has fried a batata vada with Sanjyot Keer. Is the idea of Audiard, a Palme d’Or-winning maestro, watching a Kamal Haasan rip-off really that outlandish? The genre-fluid mess that it is, Emilia Pérez certainly has origins in mainstream Indian cinema — it can go from Ekta Kapoor-style drama to Farah Khan-inspired musical in a matter of minutes. And like so many of our country’s films, its gender politics aren’t entirely above reproach.
Senna
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/80a0c/80a0c1cba04355283c4405375dc67ac1a13d2655" alt=""
Spectacularly silly, Netflix’s big-budget mini-series is the cinematic equivalent of a flat tyre
Expensive-looking but shoddily written, Netflix's biographical drama about Ayrton Senna is among the streamer's most disappointing shows of the year.
If nobody were to speak in the new Netflix show Senna, it would immediately warrant at least two extra stars. But each time any of its wafer-thin characters opens their mouths, you’re likely to be overcome by an intense desire to pump the breaks and make a pit stop, or perhaps rewatch Asif Kapadia’s seminal documentary on the subject. Based on the life and career of the legendary Brazilian Formula One driver Ayrton Senna, the six-part biographical drama is flat, uninteresting, and most criminally, boring. It is perhaps the least effective way in which his extraordinary career, and lasting influence, could’ve been commemorated.
Woman of the Hour
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/df353/df3531ed568311403442d3adc2e5593ab79ce8fd" alt=""
Anna Kendrick’s inventive serial killer thriller takes stabs in the dark
Anna Kendrick makes her directorial debut with the darkly comedic thriller, about a woman who comes face to face with a serial killer on a dating reality show. The movie is available on Lionsgate Play in India.
Sometimes, the wiser thing to do is to scale down. Not every film needs to be a sweeping epic, especially not one that demands a tight telling. Directed by the debutante Anna Kendrick, the darkly humorous thriller Woman of the Hour is based on an intriguing real-life story, but suffers from an under-confident execution. The movie would’ve worked wonderfully as a claustrophobic chamber piece, but feels compelled to jump across timelines and juggle between characters with an haphazardness that only does it harm. Kendrick is like an overeager Indian mum, checking the pressure cooker more often than she needs to, thereby releasing all the steam.
All 2 reviews of Woman of the Hour here
Joy
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c16c5/c16c5c8148ceab1f66f40d2086cf843c0d93b954" alt=""
Netflix’s melodramatic and manipulative IVF origin story is an Akshay Kumar remake waiting to happen
Netflix's cloying film about the birth of IVF takes a formulaic approach to what could have been a radical narrative
A well-intentioned drama that teeters on the edge of self-parody, Joy is a film that absolutely deserved to be made, but certainly not in this form. Some years ago, the utterly forgotten The Current War had all the messy ingenuity that a film about the creation of literal electricity demanded — the movie’s tone captured the spirit of its themes. Joy, which dramatises the events leading up to the first in vitro fertilisation (IVF) birth, would have you believe that all conception — let alone that of the artificial kind — is a cakewalk.
The Piano Lesson
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e8712/e8712a68edcfab12a7c17ccb7a151d3695345d2d" alt=""
Near-perfect Netflix drama finds John David Washington in incendiary form
Starring John David Washington and directed by his brother, Malcolm, the new Netflix movie is a tightly-wound drama about sibling bonds, inherited trauma, and the horrors of the past.
It is easy, one would imagine, for a filmmaker to be overwhelmed by the words of the great August Wilson. Especially if they’ve never made a film before. Musical and marauding, the Pulitzer Prize-winning playwright’s language is a vessel for the ambition and anger of his people. Netflix’s The Piano Lesson — the latest adaptation of Wilson’s celebrated Pittsburgh Cycle of plays — is directed by the debutante Malcolm Washington, whose father, the legendary Denzel Washington, has publicly devoted this stage of his career to shepherding Wilson’s work onto the screen.
Girls Will Be Girls
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/191a8/191a8bcecab2d8e932dd5de1440ae1ba54f26297" alt=""
Shuchi Talati’s searing psychological drama is one of the best films of the year
Featuring an electric central performance by newcomer Preeti Panigrahi, director Shuchi Talati's debut film is among the best of the year.
Like its protagonist, director Shuchi Talati’s Girls Will Be Girls is a constantly evolving entity. But behind an outer veneer of control, there is burgeoning angst, a simmering chaos, and a terrible desire to be seen and heard. The psychological drama played to an uncommonly interactive packed crowd at the Dharamshala International Film Festival recently — it was a bizarre screening that exemplified how important it is to watch movies in a community environment. Often, these experiences reveal more about society than the films themselves.
All 10 reviews of Girls Will Be Girls here
Singham Again
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8c0fe/8c0fe308f15616e4707d35665f7fc33ee3b0d05e" alt=""
Rohit Shetty’s outdated action film looks down upon its target audience; no wonder the Cop Universe is imploding
Replete with tired plot tropes and outdated ideas, Rohit Shetty's Singham Again has plenty of stars, but not an ounce of the values that its target audience might resonate with.
There is an early scene in Singham Again where Ajay Devgn’s titular super-cop barges into his teenage son’s party along with a couple of cronies, embarrasses him in public, and hauls him back home. He does it, it seems, only to give director Rohit Shetty another opportunity to shoot him in stylised slow-motion. At home, Singham and his wife, Avni (Kareena Kapoor Khan) lecture their son about how out of touch he is with Indian values. It’s a deeply melodramatic moment; you can almost imagine them turning into Amitabh Bachchan and Hema Malini from Baghban in a couple of decades. But one thing is made absolutely clear by this early domestic drama: Shetty and Devgn don’t think too highly of the nation’s youth. This became a recurring theme even in their pre-release press interviews. They would both proudly declare that they barely resonate with the kids these days, and how, back in their day, they were roughing it out in the real world. This is a bizarre stance to take, for multiple reasons. For one, it’s always a good idea to understand younger generations. You might just learn something; just ask Javed Akhtar. But second, Singham Again is aimed at the very demographic that Shetty and Devgn have decided to infantilise.
All 17 reviews of Singham Again here
Don't Move
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/55488/554882bb76a32fe09e6ec185187298147006ff5f" alt=""
Sam Raimi’s high concept Netflix survival thriller isn’t as smart as it thinks
The new Netflix survival thriller, produced by Sam Raimi, favours contrivances over cleverness.
A young woman grieving the death of her child treks to the cliffside spot where he died. She intends to jump herself. Played by Kelsey Asbille, the woman is approached by a mysterious stranger, played by Finn Wittrock. He recognises immediately that she’s one step away from falling to her death. The stranger doesn’t attempt to talk her down from the ledge, but he makes enough of an impression for her to reconsider. They walk back together to the parking lot, where things take a sudden turn. The man injects her with some kind of paralytic substance, revealing that he isn’t a good samaritan after all. Thus begins Don’t Move, a high-concept thriller that producer Sam Raimi probably thought was going to turn out like his knockout 2016 film Don’t Breathe. It didn’t. These movies have nothing in common beyond Raimi’s involvement, and that gentle nudge of a title. In terms of quality, they couldn’t be further apart from each other. Don’t Move appears to be so pleased with its premise — it’s a survival thriller featuring an immobile protagonist! — that it forgets it needs to sustain this early momentum. The movie succeeds in drawing your sympathies for its heroine, Iris, but struggles to put her in interesting scenarios after this pre-credits sequence.
All 2 reviews of Don't Move here
Santosh
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7e79e/7e79ec5dfe08de2d17f45d6c8104619fb39819cf" alt=""
Shahana Goswami shines in Sandhya Suri’s bleak crime drama that serves as a rebuttal to Rohit Shetty’s Cop Universe
A cracking two-hander between Shahana Goswami and Sunita Rajwar, director Sandhya Suri's crime drama is intent on exposing the audience's biases.
A few years ago, there was an uproar over a scene of sustained violence in director Kathryn Bigelow’s Detroit, a period crime drama about a real-life incident that led to the deaths of three young men. The controversial scene unfolded across several uncomfortable minutes, and showed a group of white police officers beat down a lineup of innocent Black men. Bigelow didn’t avert her eyes from the horror, and instead, caught the audience by the scruff of the neck and made them watch. The film’s examination of ingrained racism, police brutality, and the systemic oppression of minorities drew parallels to modern-day America, but it also divided audiences. Director Sandhya Suri’s Santosh, which was screened at the recent Dharamshala International Film Festival, unpacks similar themes, but in the context of contemporary north India. Like Detroit, it pivots on a scene of unrelenting brutality that transforms it from a standard police procedural into something more haunting.